A fierce court battle unfolds over the cuddly world of plush toys.

  • Squishmallows, a popular plush toy, is embroiled in a legal battle with Build-A-Bear over alleged copyright infringement.
  • Jazwares, the maker of Squishmallows, has filed numerous lawsuits against companies producing knockoffs.
  • Build-A-Bear launched its Skoosherz line, claiming they are unique and not copies of Squishmallows.
  • The legal dispute raises questions about intellectual property rights in the stuffed toy industry.
  • A California judge allowed the case to proceed, rejecting Build-A-Bear’s motion to dismiss.
  • The outcome could impact the competitive landscape of the plush toy market.

The Squishmallow, a beloved hybrid stuffed toy and pillow, gained immense popularity during the pandemic as people sought comfort in its huggable designs. However, behind this cuteness lies a serious legal battle. Jazwares, the company behind Squishmallows, has filed over three dozen lawsuits against various companies for producing alleged knockoffs. While some cases have been dismissed, a significant confrontation is brewing with Build-A-Bear, which is expanding its offerings beyond customizable stuffed animals. Earlier this year, Build-A-Bear introduced its Skoosherz line, marketed as ‘uniquely styled for optimal squishing and hugging benefits.’ This launch coincided with National Hugging Day, aiming to provide extra plush and adorable toys for consumers. Jazwares responded by suing Build-A-Bear in Florida, claiming that Skoosherz are direct copies of their products, citing similarities in designs like rainbow bears and green frogs. The judge did not take immediate action on this case. Subsequently, Jazwares filed a lawsuit in California, arguing that Build-A-Bear copied the ‘trade dress’ of Squishmallows. In response, Build-A-Bear sought a declaration in Missouri that their Skoosherz were not copies, accusing Jazwares of being overly litigious. The stuffed toy market is lucrative, with Build-A-Bear generating $486 million in revenue last year and Squishmallow sales exceeding $200 million in 2022. The legal proceedings are set to get complicated as both companies exchange evidence, with Jazwares alleging that Build-A-Bear pressured a manufacturer into creating copycat toys. The outcome of this case could significantly affect the plush toy industry, as it raises important questions about consumer confusion and the distinctiveness of toy designs. As the case unfolds, the plush toy community watches closely, with opinions divided on the similarities between Squishmallows and Skoosherz.·

Factuality Level: 7
Factuality Justification: The article provides a detailed account of the legal disputes between Jazwares and Build-A-Bear regarding the Squishmallows and Skoosherz products. While it presents factual information about the lawsuits and the companies involved, it includes some subjective opinions from individuals, which could affect its objectivity. Additionally, there are moments of redundancy and tangential details that could distract from the main focus of the article.·
Noise Level: 6
Noise Justification: The article provides a detailed account of the legal battles surrounding Squishmallows and Build-A-Bear, which is relevant and informative. However, it lacks deeper analysis of the implications of these legal disputes and does not explore broader trends or consequences in the toy industry. While it presents facts and quotes from involved parties, it does not significantly hold powerful entities accountable or provide actionable insights.·
Public Companies: Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.A), Build-A-Bear Workshop (BBW)
Private Companies: Jazwares,Ty
Key People: Warren Buffett (Chairman of Berkshire Hathaway), Charlie Munger (Former Vice Chairman of Berkshire Hathaway), Moez Kaba (Lawyer for Jazwares), Josephine Staton (U.S. District Judge), Geoffrey Potter (Attorney), Rebecca Tushnet (Harvard Law School Professor)

Track all markets on TradingView

Financial Relevance: Yes
Financial Markets Impacted: The article discusses the financial implications of the intellectual property battle between Jazwares and Build-A-Bear, both of which are significant players in the toy industry with substantial revenues.
Financial Rating Justification: The article highlights the financial stakes involved in the lawsuits over the Squishmallows and Skoosherz products, including the revenues generated by both companies, which indicates a direct impact on their financial performance and market positions.·
Presence Of Extreme Event: No
Nature Of Extreme Event: No
Impact Rating Of The Extreme Event: No
Extreme Rating Justification: The article discusses an ongoing intellectual property dispute between Jazwares and Build-A-Bear regarding the Squishmallows and Skoosherz, but it does not describe an extreme event that occurred in the last 48 hours.·
Move Size: No market move size mentioned.
Sector: All
Direction: Neutral
Magnitude: Medium
Affected Instruments: Stocks

Reported publicly: www.wsj.com